* This transcript was created by voice-to-text technology. The transcript has not been edited for errors or omissions, it is for reference only and is not the official minutes of the meeting. [00:04:18] OKAY. GOOD EVENING. [CALL TO ORDER] MY NAME IS KEVIN MAGU. I'M THE VICE CHAIR AND I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION MEETING TO ORDER FOR JULY 30TH, 2024. MADAM CLERK, [ROLL CALL] PLEASE CALL THE ROLL CHAIR IRVINE VICE CHAIR. GAN PRESENT. COMMISSIONER BODEK. COMMISSIONER GIFE PRESENT. COMMISSIONER HUNTER PRESENT. COMMISSIONER PIZZA PRESENT. COMMISSIONER PRYOR, WE HAVE QUORUM. THANK YOU FOR THE RECORD. [00:05:01] CHAIR IRVINE. COMMISSIONER BOECK AND COMMISSIONER PRYOR ARE EXCUSED FROM THE MEETING. ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION? NO. THANK YOU. UH, AT THIS, AT THIS TIME, [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] I'D LIKE TO HAVE EVERYONE STAND AND RECITE THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. PLEASE PAY PLACE YOUR HAND OVER YOUR HEART. READY BEGIN. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH, WITH LIBERTY. JUSTICE ALL THANK YOU. YOU CAN BE SEATED. BEFORE WE BEGIN OUR MEETING, UH, IF ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA TODAY, I'D LIKE TO SWEAR OF THE WITNESSES. IF YOU PLEASE STAND. IT IS NOW TIME TO SWEAR OF THE WITNESSES. IF YOU'RE GOING TO GIVE TESTIMONY, PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND RECITE. DO YOU SOLEMNLY SWEAR TO AFFIRM THAT THE EVIDENCE YOU SHALL GIVE TO THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION MEETING SHALL BE THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH? THANK YOU. WE'LL BEGIN OUR REGULAR AGENDA, [1. 24-54288 Recommendation to receive and file Director’s Report.       Suggested Action: Approve recommendation. ] RECOMMEND AND RECEIVE THE RE THE DIRECTOR'S REPORT. GOOD EVENING, VICE CHAIR AND COMMISSIONERS. THIS IS ADVANCED PLANNING OFFICER ALEJANDRO SANTO LOPEZ TO GIVE OUR DIRECTOR'S REPORT TODAY. I'LL TURN IT OVER TO OUR HISTORIC PRESERVATION SENIOR PLANNER, ALEJANDRO PLACENCIA. AND BEFORE WE MOVE FORWARD, MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO RECEIVE THIS ITEM? YES. CAN I ENTERTAIN A MOTION? SO MOVED AND A SECOND. UH, COMMISSIONER GFI SECONDS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. OKAY, THANK YOU. UM, SO, UH, FOR THE DIRECTOR'S REPORT, UH, THERE'S A FEW ITEMS THAT WE HAVE FOR TONIGHT. UH, PROBABLY THE FIRST ONE IS, IS THAT ON AN UPCOMING AGENDA HERE, PROBABLY WITHIN THE NEXT MONTH OR SO, UH, WE'LL BE BRINGING YOU, UH, AN ANNUAL REPORT. SO THE ANNUAL REPORT IS ONE THAT IS, UH, ONE SPECIFICALLY FOR THE CITY. UH, IN THE PAST, THIS COMMISSION HAS SEEN AN ANNUAL REPORT THAT GOES TO THE STATE. SO THAT'S ONE OF THE ONLY DISTINCTIONS IN HERE IS, IS THAT THIS IS ONE THAT IS, UM, GOING DIRECTLY BACK TO THE CITY AND IT'LL GO BACK TO THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE. AND THIS'LL BE A REPORT THAT REALLY, UH, JUST DESCRIBES, UH, THE COMMISSION'S ACTIVITIES THROUGHOUT THE YEAR. UH, SO HOW MANY PUBLIC HEARINGS YOU HAVE, UM, ATTENDANCE, UM, THINGS LIKE THAT THAT'LL REALLY GO INTO THIS REPORT. SO THAT'LL BE SOMETHING THAT WE'LL HAVE YOU VOTE ON, UM, LIKE I SAID, IN THE COMING MONTHS. UH, THE OTHER UPDATE IS, IS THAT, UH, AS THE COMMISSION KNOWS, WE HAD ONE CHC WORKSHOP, UH, THAT WAS IN FEBRUARY, AND WE'RE, UH, CITY STAFF IS STILL WORKING TO, UH, ARRANGE THE SECOND WORKSHOP. SO WE'RE LIKELY GOING TO SEE THAT, UH, WORKSHOP BE SCHEDULED EITHER ON AN AGENDA HERE AT, UM, IN CHAMBERS, UH, LIKELY IN THE FALL, OR, UH, WE MIGHT BREAK THAT UP INTO TWO. I THINK JUST, UH, FOR THE COMMISSION'S BENEFIT, IT'S A, IT'S A LARGE, UH, TRAINING, SO IT'S A LOT TO DO IN, IN, IN ONE MEETING HERE AT THE CHAMBERS. SO THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE THAT WE MIGHT BREAK THAT ONE UP AND MAYBE HAVE PART OF IT OFFSITE. UH, THE LAST UPDATE IS, IS THAT, UH, COMMISSIONER IRVINE, OR EXCUSE ME, APOLOGIZE, UH, CHAIR IRVINE. UH, HER TERM IS TERM IS TERMED OUT NOW. UH, WE MIGHT STILL HAVE, UH, CHAIR IRVINE FOR ONE MORE MEETING. UH, BUT IN ADDITION TO THAT, WE ALSO WANT TO POINT OUT THAT THE CITY, UH, THE MAYOR'S OFFICE, UH, APPOINTED A NEW, UH, COMMISSIONER. SO HER NAME IS JACQUELINE PADILLA PEREZ. UH, SO AS SOON AS WE GET HER UP TO SPEED, AS THIS COMMISSION KNOWS, THERE'S A LOT OF REQUIREMENTS THAT YOU HAVE TO DO BEHIND THE SCENES, UH, TO BECOME A COMMISSIONER. SO AS, UH, SHE GETS THROUGH THAT PROCESS AND WE DO OUR ONBOARDING AND TRAINING, UH, WE SHOULD HAVE, UH, COMMISSIONER PADILLA PEREZ, UM, START, UM, HER DUTY ON THE DAIS, UH, PROBABLY WITHIN THE NEXT COUPLE OF MONTHS. AND THAT IS IT FOR THE DIRECTOR'S REPORT TODAY. THANK YOU. UH, COMMISSIONERS, ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE DIRECTOR'S REPORT? UM, AT THIS TIME, WE'LL TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT. ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THE DIRECTOR'S REPORT. PLEASE LINE UP IN FRONT OF THE MICROPHONE IF THERE IS NONE. IS THERE ANY VIRTUAL COMMENTS? [00:10:08] THERE APPEARS TO BE NO VIRTUAL COMMENTS. THANK YOU. MADAM CLERK, PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE. VICE CHAIRMAN GU, IF YOU'D LIKE TO GIVE A VOICE VOTE, I CAN TAKE THAT. VICE CHAIRMAN GUAN? YES. WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE A VOICE VOTE YAY OR NAY? UH, YAY. THANK YOU. MOTION CARRIES. THANK YOU. [2. 24-54289 Recommendation to approve the minutes for the Cultural Heritage Commission meeting of Tuesday, March 26, 2024.       Suggested Action: Approve recommendation. ] RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION MEETING OF TUESDAY, MARCH 26TH, 2024. MAY I HAVE A MOTION ON THIS ITEM? COMMISSIONER GFI MOVES. OH, SORRY. UM, UH, SECOND, UH, SECOND COMMISSIONER GFI SECONDS. THANK YOU. IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS OF THE AUDIENCE THAT WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE MINUTES, PLEASE LINE UP AT THE PODIUM. THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE CHAMBERS. ARE THERE ANY COMMENTS VIRTUALLY? IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE? UM, PLEASE USE THE RAISE HAND MOTION NOW OR JOINING TELEPHONICALLY. PLEASE PRESS STAR NINE. NOW. THERE APPEARS TO BE NO PUBLIC COMMENT. IF THERE IS NONE, MAY I HAVE THE CALL FOR THE VOTE, PLEASE? I VERBALLY, YES. MOTION CARRIES. THANK YOU, . NOW WE'RE GETTING TO THE GOOD STUFF. UM, MAY I HAVE A [3. 24-54291 Recommendation to request City Council designate 82 Rivo Alto Canal, 4210 California Avenue, and 4401 Myrtle Avenue as Historic Landmark buildings; and Request City Council approve Mills Act contracts for the following 14 properties: 82 Rivo Alto Canal, 293 Temple Avenue, 422 West 11th Street, 445 West 4th Street, 519 West 10th Street, 746 Dawson Avenue, 802 Dawson Avenue, 834 Dawson Avenue, 2425 East 2nd Street, 3720 Olive Avenue, 3753 Gundry Avenue, 4210 California Avenue, 4401 Myrtle Avenue, and 6050 Walnut Avenue. (Districts 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9)       Suggested Action: Approve recommendation. ] MOTION TO HEAR THIS ITEM RECOMMENDED TO REQUEST CITY COUNCIL TO DESIGNATE 82 REVO ALTO CANAL, 4 2 1 0 CALIFORNIA AVENUE, 44 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE AS HISTORICAL LANDMARK BUILDINGS AND REQUEST THE CITY COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE MILLS ACT CONTRACT FOR THE FOLLOWING 14 PROPERTIES, 82 REVA ALTO CANAL, 2 93 TEMPLE AVENUE, 4 22 WEST 11TH STREET, 4 45 WEST FOURTH STREET, FIVE 19 WEST 10TH STREET, 7 49 DAWSON AVENUE, 8 0 2 DAWSON AVENUE, 8 34 DIVISION, UH, DAWSON AVENUE, 24 25 EAST SECOND STREET, 37 20 OLIVE AVENUE, 37 53 GUNDRY AVENUE, 42 10 CALIFORNIA AVENUE, 40 40 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE, 6 0 5 OH WALNUT AVENUE. IT ENCOMPASSES DISTRICTS 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, AND NINE. MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO HEAR THIS ITEM? COMMISSIONER HUNTER? SO MOVED. WE HAVE A MOTION FROM, UH, COMMISSIONER PIZZA AND A SECOND FROM COMMISSIONER HUNTER. A SECOND. THANK YOU. CAN WE HEAR THE PRESENTATION FROM THE STAFF? THANK YOU. SENIOR PROJECT PLANNER. JEAN? YES. WILL GIVE, UH, THE STAFF REPORT FOR THIS ITEM. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, CHAIR, CHAIR. CHAIR, CHAIR. CHAIR. CHAIR. CHAIR. CHAIR. CHAIR. CHAIR, CHAIR. YOU GOOD? [00:15:05] OKAY. WE, WE, WE, WE APOLOGIZE FOR THE TECHNICAL DIFFICULTY. TEST TEST. IS THIS BETTER? I ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU AND GOOD EVENING CHAIR AND FELLOW COMMISSIONERS. , IT IS NOT CHANGING, NOT WORKING NOW. OKAY. I AM GONNA GO AHEAD AND GET STARTED BECAUSE THE FIRST FEW SLIDES. ONE SECOND. OH, WE'RE GONNA WAIT, WAIT, WE'RE GONNA WAIT ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE SECOND. ONE, ONE SECOND. ONE, ONE. OKAY, I GONNA ECHO. ALRIGHT. UM, YEAH, I THINK WE'LL JUST HAVE YOU, UH, JUST REPEAT, REPEAT WHAT I SAID. MICROPHONE. SURE, SURE, SURE. , I WON'T GO SO CLOSE. UM, I JUST WANTED TO BRING UP, UM, THAT THERE ARE TWO PROPERTIES THAT I WAS INVOLVED WITH ON A PROFESSIONAL LEVEL IN ONE IS 44 0 1, UM, MYRTLE. I MET THE OWNERS AND I WORKED DURING 20 18, 20 19 AND 2020, UM, ON A CONSULTING HOURLY BASIS. UM, NOT A LOT OF TIME, BUT I I DID HELP THEM WITH, UM, SELECTING SOME SUBCONTRACTORS AND SOME SMALL ITEMS. UM, MOSTLY ON THE EXTERIOR ACTUALLY. UM, I MEAN, EXTERIOR LANDSCAPE, LET ME PREFACE THAT. NOT THE EXTERIOR OF THE HOME, BUT THE EXTERIOR, UH, LANDSCAPING. UM, AND THEN IN, UM, 2020, I MET, UM, THEIR OTHER FAMILY MEMBERS WHO PURCHASED 42 10 CALIFORNIA. UM, AND THEY WANTED ME TO COME AND CONSULT, UH, WHILE THEY WERE IN ESCROW. AND THAT WAS ABOUT TWO HOURS. AND I DID THAT AND I'M NOT FEELING THAT THAT HAS, UM, ANY BEARING ON, ON, ON, ON, ON THE LANDMARK STATUS FOR THIS AND ME RECUSING [00:20:01] MYSELF. BUT I'M OPENING IT UP TO, UM, YOU TO, TO TELL ME IF THERE'S ANY CONFLICT OF INTEREST IN THAT. UM, DO YOU HAVE ANY, UM, DIRECT, UH, PECUNIARY INTEREST IN THESE PROPERTIES? NO, I DO NOT. UH, THEN YOU CAN VOTE. GREAT. THANK YOU. OKAY, WE'RE GONNA TRY THIS AGAIN. UH, THANK YOU. THIS IS THE ZA PROGRAM, UH, CONTRACTS AND LANDMARK REQUEST. UH, THANK YOU. E UH, GOOD, GOOD EVENING CHAIR AND FELLOW COMMISSIONERS. THE MILLS ACT WAS ENACTED BY STATE LAW IN 1972. IT ALLOWS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO ENTER INTO TAX ABATEMENT CONTRACTS WITH PROPERTY OWNERS OF HISTORIC STRUCTURES IN EXCHANGE FOR COMMITMENT TO HISTORIC PRESERVATION WORK PROGRAM FOR THEIR PROPERTY. PROPERTY OWNERS PROPOSE A WORK PLAN AS PART OF THEIR PART OF THEIR CONTRACT AND AGREE TO RESTORE AND MAINTAIN, PRESERVE THE PROPERTY IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFIC HISTORIC PRESERVATION STANDARDS. THE CITY OF LONG BEACH MILLS ACT PROGRAM WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1993 AND UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE STATE LEGISLATION, THE PROGRAM PROVIDES A FINANCIAL INCENTIVE FOR PROPERTY OWNERS UNDERTAKING RESTORATION, REHABILITATION, OR MAINTENANCE OF THEIR DESIGNATED HISTORIC PROPERTY. STAFF CONDUCTED OUTREACH TO NOTIFY THE PUBLIC, UM, INVITED, UH, PROPERTY OWNERS TO APPLY FOR THE MILLS ACT PROGRAM AND TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE WITH THE APPLICATION PROCESS. THE FIRST MANDATORY PRE-APPLICATION WORKSHOP WAS HELD AT THE ERNEST MCBRIDE PARK AND REC COMMUNITY CENTER ON JANUARY 20TH, 2024. THERE ARE APPROXIMATELY 60 PEOPLE IN ATTENDANCE. THE SECOND MANDATORY WORKSHOP WAS HELD VIRTUALLY ON FEBRUARY 10TH, 2024, AND WAS ATTENDED BY APPROXIMATELY 54 PEOPLE. THE FIRST PRE-APPLICATION WORKSHOP IS INTENDED TO PROVIDE GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE MILLS ACT PROGRAM, UH, PROPERTY CRITERIA AND THE BENEFITS OF THE PROGRAM IN GENERAL. AND THE SECOND WORKSHOP PROVIDES A MORE DETAILED PROGRAM INFORMATION STAFF ASSISTANCE WITH APPLICATIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE GENERAL PUBLIC. TO ASK SPECIFIC QUESTIONS, STAFF, UH, IMPLEMENTED A MULTIFACTOR FAXED OUTREACH APPROACH TO GET THE INFORMATION OUT TO THE PUBLIC, WHICH INCLUDED MULTIPLE EMAIL BLASTS, REMINDERS OF THE WORKSHOPS, AS WELL AS PROMOTION ON SEVERAL MEDIA, SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS TO BUILD UPON THE RECENT EFFORTS TO INCREASE RECOGNI RECOGNITION AND PRESERVATION OF THE COMMUNITY HISTORIES THAT ARE, ARE CURRENTLY UNDERSERVED IN THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROGRAM. UM, WE, UM, DID AN OUTREACH STRATEGY, WHICH INCLUDED, UM, VIDEOS, UM, WHERE WE, WE RECORDED VIDEOS AND POSTED THEM UP FOR THE PUBLIC. UH, THE VIDEOS WERE IN ENGLISH, SPANISH, AND KAMAI, AND THEY WERE SHARED ON THE MILLS ACT WEB PAGE AND SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS. TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE MILLS ACT PROGRAM, A BUILDING MUST BE CURRENTLY DESIGNATED AS A LANDMARK, BE ELIGIBLE FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION AND COMPLETE THE DESIGNATION PROCESS, OR BE A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE LOCATED IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT. THE APPLICATION CATEGORIES ARE BASED ON PROPERTY TYPE AND HAVE A CORRESPONDING ANNUAL LIMIT OF CONTRACTS THAT CAN BE AWARDED FOR EACH PROPERTY TYPE. A MAXIMUM OF 12 CONTRACTS CAN BE AWARDED PER YEAR TO SINGLE FAMILY PROPERTIES, THREE CONTRACTS PER YEAR FOR THE DUPLEX OR TRIPLEX PROPERTIES, AND FOUR CONTRACTS TO MULTI-FAMILY PROPERTIES, UH, WITH FOUR UNITS OR GREATER, AND ONE CONTRACT TO EACH NON-RESIDENTIAL, WHICH WOULD BE COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL OR IS INSTITUTIONAL PROPERTIES. AND TWO CONTRACTS, REGARDLESS OF THE PROPERTY TYPE, IF THE PROPERTY IS DEEMED TO BE EXCEPTIONAL, UM, WOULD FALL INTO THAT CATEGORY. IN ADDITION TO BEING HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT, THE PROPERTY MUST NOT EXCEED THE VALUATION THRESHOLD LIMIT SET FOR SINGLE FAMILY DUPLEX OR TRIPLEX, OR THE NON-RESIDENTIAL CATEGORY. UNDER THE CURRENT PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS, A TOTAL OF 22 MEALS AT CONTRACTS CAN BE AWARDED IN A TYPICAL YEAR ACROSS VARIOUS PROPERTY TYPES. OF THE 18 APPLICATIONS FILED THIS YEAR. 13 APPLICATIONS WERE RECEIVED FROM THE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL CATEGORY THREE WERE FROM THE DUPLEX AND TRIPLEX CA CATEGORY, AND ONE WAS FROM THE MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL CATEGORY, AND ONE WAS FROM THE NON-RESIDENTIAL CATEGORY OR COMMERCIAL. THREE APPLICATIONS INCLUDED NEW LANDMARK DESIGNATION REQUESTS. [00:25:01] MOST OF THE APPLICATIONS WE RECEIVED ARE FROM THE SOUTHERN PART OF THE CITY. WHILE THERE ARE HISTORIC PROPERTIES THROUGHOUT ALL OF LONG BEACH, THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE CITY RETAINS THE HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS OF OLDER BUILDING STOCK AND HAS THE LARGEST NUMBER OF HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND HISTORICALLY DESIGNATED PROPERTIES, WHICH EXPLAINS WHY THERE'S A LARGER NUMBER OF APPLICATIONS IN COUNCIL. DISTRICTS ONE AND TWO WITH 12 APPLICATIONS, COUNCIL DISTRICT FIVE RECEIVED THE SECOND HIGHEST CONCENTRATION OF APPLICATIONS WITH FOUR APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED, AND THE CALIFORNIA HEIGHTS HISTORIC DISTRICT IS LOCATED IN COUNCIL DISTRICT FIVE OUT OF THE 18 APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED THIS YEAR, STAFF IS RECOMMENDING 14 APPLICATIONS FOR MILL ATK CONTRACTS. 10 APPLICATIONS ARE FROM THE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL CATEGORY. THREE APPLICATIONS ARE FROM THE DUPLEX AND TRIPLEX CATEGORY, AND ONE APPLICATION IS AMONGST THE EXCEPTIONAL ARCHITECTURAL CATEGORY, AS IT IS EXCEEDS A THRESHOLD FOR VALUATION. UH, THE NEXT SLIDES WILL HIGHLIGHT EACH OF THE 14 PROPERTIES THAT STAFF IS RECOMMENDING FORWARD FOR CONTRACT WARDENS. THE MILLS THAT THE WORK PLANS FOR THESE PROPERTIES REFLECT A BROAD RANGE OF IMPROVEMENTS THAT WOULD SUPPORT PRESERVATION ON THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES RANGING FROM FOUNDATION REPAIRS, RE-ROOF, EXTERIOR SIDING, REPAIRS, PLUMBING AND ELECTRICAL UPGRADES, WINDOW RESTORATION, REHABILITATION, AND OTHER REPLACEMENTS. THE FIRST ONE ON OUR LIST TO GET STARTED IS 82 REVO ALTO CANAL. IT'S A TWO STORY RESIDENCE. IT WAS DESIGNED IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. IT'S CONSTRUCTED IN 1961. UH, THE BUILDING FEATURES, UH, POSTON BEAM CONSTRUCTION WITH SMOOTH, UM, STUCCO WALLS. AND THE RECOMMENDATION FOR MILLS ACT APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE PROPERTY OBTAINING A LANDMARK DESIGNATION. THE SECOND PROPERTY ON THIS SLIDE IS 2 93 TEMPLE AVENUE. IT'S A ONE STORY CRAFTSMAN RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1918. IT FEATURES A FRONT FACING GABLE ROOF SYSTEM, WOOD WINDOWS, HORIZONTAL WOOD PLANK, EXTERIOR SIDING, AND AN OFF-CENTERED PORCH SUPPORTED BY TWO WIDE BRICK AND POST COLUMNS. THIS SLIDE SHOWS 4 22 WEST 11TH STREET AS A TWO STORY CRAFTSMAN RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1913. IT FEATURES A FRONT FACING GABLE ROOF SYSTEM WITH EXPOSED ROOF RAPTOR RAFTER AND BEAMS, HORIZONTAL HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING AND DOUBLE HUNG WOOD WINDOWS 4, 4 45 AND 4 43 A AND B WEST FOURTH STREET CONSISTS OF TWO DETACHED BUILDINGS. THE FRONT BUILDING IS A ONE STORY VERNACULAR RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1901. IT'S LOCATED AT THE FRONT OF THE LOT. THE VERNACULAR RESIDENCE FEATURES A HIP ROOF SYSTEM WITH SMALL SIDE FACING GABLES, EXTERIOR WOOD, HORIZONTAL SIDING, WOOD WINDOWS, AND A LARGE COVERED PORCH. A ONE STORY CRAFTSMAN DUPLEX CONSTRUCTED IN 1930 IS LOCATED AT THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY. THE CRAFTSMAN DUPLEX FEATURES A FRONT FACING GABLE WOOD WINDOWS, HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING. BOTH BUILDINGS ARE INTACT AND FEATURE ORIGINAL EXTERIOR FEATURES, AND THE WORK PLAN INCLUDES RESTORATION OF BOTH BUILDINGS. FIVE 19 WEST 10TH STREET IS A TWO STORY CRAFTSMAN THAT FEATURES FRONT AND SIDE GABLE ROOF SYSTEMS WIDE OVERHANGING EXPOSED ROOF EAVES AND POLES, HORIZONTAL EXTERIOR WOOD SIDING, DOUBLE HUNG WOOD WINDOWS, AND A COVERED PORCH SUPPORTED BY COL SQUARE COLUMNS AND POSTS. 7 43 DAWSON AVENUE IS A ONE STORY CRAFTS IN BUNGALOW CONSTRUCTED IN 1914. IT FEATURES A SIDE FACING CLIPPED GABLE ROOF, HORIZONTAL EXTERIOR WOOD SIDING, WOOD WINDOWS, AND A LARGE RAISED PORCH STRUC SUPPORTED BY FOUR DOOR COLUMNS SUPPORTING A FRONT FACING CLIPPED GABLE ROOF STRUCTURE. 8 0 2 DAWSON AVENUE AND 2215 EAST EIGHTH STREET IS DEVELOPED WITH TWO DETACHED DWELLINGS. THE PRIMARY RESIDENCE ADDRESSED AS 8 0 2. DAWSON AVENUE WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1919 IN THE CRAFTSMAN STYLE FEATURES, AN ENCLOSED FRONT PORCH AND ATTACHED WOOD TRELLIS SUPPORTED BY TWO WIDE BRICK COLUMNS. THE SECONDARY RESIDENCE, UH, AT 2215 EAST EIGHTH STREET WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1923 IN THE CRAFTSMAN STYLE. AND THIS, UM, DWELLING FEATURES A FRONT FACING GABLE ROOF, COVERED FRONT PORCH, EXTERIOR WOOD SIDING, AND WOOD WINDOWS. 8 34 DAWSON AVENUE IS A ONE STORY CRAFTSMAN RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1917. IT FEATURES A FRONT FACING GABLE ROOF WITH EXPOSED EAVES AND BEAMS, UNPAINTED EXTERIOR WOOD SHINGLE SIDING, AND THREE SQUARE BRICK COLUMNS SUPPORTING A WIDE COVERED PORCH AND WOOD WINDOWS [00:30:07] 24, 25 AND 24 27. EAST SECOND STREET WAS DEVELOPED WITH TWO BUILDINGS. THE FRONT BUILDING IS A TWO STORY SPANISH COLONIAL REVIVAL. RESIDENTIAL DWELLING CONSTRUCTED IN 1922, FEATURES A FLAT ROOF, UH, UM, ACCENTED WITH RED CLAY ROOF TILES, UH, EXTERIOR STUCCO WALLS, UH, WOOD FRAME DOORS AND WINDOWS, AND A CIRCULAR COVERED PORCH SUPPORTED BY DORK WHITE COLUMNS. THE REAR BUILDING IS A GARAGE WITH AN APARTMENT LOCATED ABOVE, WHICH WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1915. THE STRUCTURE WAS CONSTRUCTED IN THE CRAFTSMAN ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. IT FEATURES A LOW PITCHED HIP ROOF, HIP ROOFED, EXPOSED OVERHANGING EAVES AND EXTERIOR HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING 32 20 OLIVE AVENUE IS A ONE STORY SPANISH COLONIAL REVIVAL. CONSTRUCTED IN 1925, FEATURES A FLAT ROOF WITH RED CLAY ROOF TILES, EXTERIOR STUCCO, AND WOOD WINDOWS 37 53. GUNDRY AVENUE IS A ONE STORY SPANISH COLONIAL REVIVAL CONSTRUCTED IN 1930, FEATURING FRONT AND SIDE FACING GABLE ROOF STRUCTURE WITH RED CLAY ROOF TILES, EXTERIOR STUCCO WALLS, WOOD WINDOWS, AND ATTACHED PORT RICOCHET. 42 10. CALIFORNIA IS A ONE STORY CUSTOM RANCH RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1964. IT FEATURES A U-SHAPED HORIZONTAL BUILDING FORM WITH AN INTERIOR COURTYARD POST AND BEAM STYLE CONSTRUCTION WITH SMOOTH STUCCO WALLS, A LOW PITCHED ROOF WITH WIDE OVERHANGING EAVES AND AN OPEN INTERIOR FLOOR PLAN THAT INTEGRATES THE OUTDOORS INTO THE INTERIOR WITH THE USE OF LARGE WINDOWS AND GLASS DOORS. THE RECOMME RECOMMENDATION FOR MILLS ACT IS SUBJECT TO THIS BUILDING, OBTAINING LANDMARK DESIGNATION STATUS 4 44 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE IS A TWO STORY RESIDENTIAL RESIDENCE DESIGNATED, I'M SORRY, DESIGNED IN THE INTER INTERNATIONAL ARCHITECTURAL STYLE CONSTRUCTED IN 1936. IT FEATURES FLAT, A FLAT ROOF, CONCRETE SMOOTH STUCCO AND GLASS EXTERIOR WALLS, STILL FRAMED WINDOWS AND DOORS. THE RECOMME RECOMMENDATION FOR THE MILLS ACT IS SUBJECT TO THIS BUILDING OBTAINING LANDMARK DESIGNATION. THE LAST CONTRACT, UH, RECOMMENDED FORWARD IS 60 50 WALNUT AVENUE. IT'S A ONE STORY SPANISH COLONIAL REVIVAL CONSTRUCTED IN 1928. IT FEATURES A FLAT ROOF, RED CLAY ROOF TILES, EXTERIOR STUCCO WALLS, AND WOOD WINDOWS. SLIDE, UM, IDENTIFIES THE FOUR, UM, APPLICATIONS THAT ARE NOT BEING RECOMMENDED FORWARD. OUT OF 18 APPLICATIONS WE RECEIVED, THE PROPERTIES ARE TWO 60 OR ZABA AVENUE. UM, IT DIDN'T QUALIFY 'CAUSE IT WAS A NON CONTRIBUTOR, UH, ONE 10 PINE AVENUE. UH, THIS BUILDING WAS A, IS A HISTORIC LANDMARK BUILDING, BUT, UH, THE WORK PLAN WASN'T ROBUST ENOUGH TO MOVE FORWARD. UH, 1100 EAST THIRD STREET. AGAIN, IT'S A, A HISTORIC LANDMARK BUILDING, BUT THEY, THEIR WORK PLAN WASN'T ROBUST ENOUGH AND 37 57 GARDENA AVENUE. UM, THE WORK PLAN WASN'T ROBUST ENOUGH AS STATED PREVIOUSLY. THERE ARE THREE APPLICATIONS, UM, REQUESTING LANDMARK DESIGNATION 82 VILLE ALTO CANAL, 42 10 CALIFORNIA AVENUE, AND 44 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE. AND TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION, A CULTURAL RESOURCE MUST RETAIN INTEGRITY AND MEET ONE OF THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA. IT IS ASSOCIATED WITH THE EVENTS THAT HAVE MADE A SIGNIFICANT, SIGNIFICANT CONTRIBUTION TO THE BROAD PATTERNS OF THE CITY'S HISTORY. IT IS ASSOCIATED WITH THE LIVES OF PERSONS SIGNIFICANT IN THE CITY'S PAST. IT EMBODIES THE DISTINCTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF A TYPE PERIOD OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION, OR IT REPRESENTS THE WORK OF A MASTER WHERE IT POSSESSES HIGH ARCHITECT ARTISTIC VALUES, OR IT HAS YIELDED OR IT'S LIKELY TO YIELD IMPORTANT INFORMATION IN PRE-HISTORY OR HISTORY. WELL, THE FIRST LANDMARK APPLICATION IS 82 REBEL ALTO CANAL. THIS IS A TWO STORY RESIDENCE CONSTRUCTED IN 1961. IT WAS DESIGNED IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. THE BUILDING WAS COMMISSIONED BY EDWARD FRANK FOR THE ARTS AND ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE CASE HOUSE PROGRAM, AND IT WAS DESIGNED BY EDWARD KILLINGSWORTH OF THE ARCHITECTURAL FIRM, KILLINGSWORTH BRADY AND SMITH. THE BUILDING FEATURES POST AND BEAM CONSTRUCTION, SMOOTH STUCCO [00:35:01] WALLS. THE FRONT FACADE FEATURES A PAIR OF DOUBLE HEIGHT WINDOWS AND REFLECTING POOL WITH FLOATING STEPS THAT LEAD TO THE 17 FOOT TALL ENTRY DOOR. AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE PHOTO, THE REFLECTING POOL EXTENDS BEYOND THE FRONT DOOR AND INTO THE PRIVATE, UM, ATRIUM. THE POND EXTENDS ALONG THE ENTIRE LEFT SIDE OF THE ATRIUM, WHICH CREATES A TRANQUIL INDOOR OUTDOOR SPACE. A LARGE SLIDING GLASS DOOR SYSTEM PROVIDES ACCESS TO ACCESS TO THE INSIDE OF THE HOUSE. FROM THE ATRIUM. EDWARD FRANK, WHO COMMISSIONED THE REVO ALTO CANAL AS HIS HOME AND HIS BROTHER MAURICE FRANK, WERE THE CO-OWNERS OF THE FRANK BROTHERS FURNITURE LOCATED IN LONG BEACH. IT WAS A STORE THAT PIONEERED THE FIELD OF MODERN FURNITURE RETAILING DURING THE MID 20TH CENTURY. THEIR BUSINESS AND DESIGN STRATEGIES CULTIVATED A POINT OF VIEW THAT BECAME SYNONYMOUS WITH GOOD TASTE IN MODERNISM. THE CLIENTELE FOR INTERIOR DESIGN AND CUSTOM UPHOLSTER UPHOLSTERY SERVICES THE STORE OFFERED WAS CONCENTRATED IN THE GREATER LONG BEACH AREA. BUT THEIR INFLUENCE EXTENDED WELL BEYOND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. THE COMPANY CLOSELY COLLABORATED WITH ARCHITECTS AND DESIGNERS TO CROSS PROMOTE MODERN DESIGN. THE FRANK BROTHERS BUSINESS PLAYED AN ESSENTIAL ROLE IN THE SUCCESS OF THE ARTS AND ARCHITECTURE'S CASE HOUSE STUDY PROGRAM BY CULT, UH, CUL CULTURATING, THE FURNISHINGS TO COMPLIMENT THE ARCHITECTURAL ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE PER RESPECTIVE BUILDINGS. BETWEEN 1945 AND 1962, THE FRANK BROTHERS STYLED A HALF A DOZEN PROJECTS PUBLISHED IN THE ARTS AND ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE, WHICH INCLUDED THIS HOUSE CASE STUDY, HOUSE NUMBER 25. KILLINGSWORTH WAS A MASTER ARCHITECT AND THE FOUNDING PARTNER OF THE ARCHITECTURE FIRM, KILLINGSWORTH BRADY AND SMITH. THEY WERE BASED OUT OF LONG BEACH AND HIS FIRM WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR SOME OF THE GREATEST MID-CENTURY STRUCTURES IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. KILLINGSWORTH IS IDENTIFIED AS A MASTER ARCHITECT AND IS SIGNIFICANT FOR HIS INTERNATIONAL STYLE AS, UH, AESTHETICS AND HIS PARTIC PARTICIPATION IN THE CASE STUDY PROGRAM. THIS PARTICULAR BUILDING IS A PROMINENT EXAMPLE OF THE INTERNATIONAL STYLE LONG BEACH WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF CALIFORNIA MODERNISM. THE BUILDING EXHIBITS CHARACTERISTICS IN THE OF THE INTERNATIONAL STYLE INCLUDES THE RECTANGULAR FORM, THE LACK OF ORNAMENTATION, A FLAT ROOF, LARGE PANES OF GLASS OPEN INTERIOR FLOOR PLANS, INCLUSIVE INCLUSION OF INNOVATIVE BUILDING MATERIALS AND TECHNIQUES. THIS HOUSE RETAINS A HIGH LEVEL INTEGRITY WITH IN TECT CHARACTER DEFINING FEATURES. THE BUILDING IS ALSO CLOSELY ASSOCIATED WITH THE ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE FRANK BROTHERS FURNITURE FIRM AS THE COMMISSION RESIDENCE IS, UM, FOR EDWARD FRANK, FRANK RESIDED HERE DURING THE FIRM'S SIGNIFICANT PERIOD OF INFLUENCE ON MODERN INTERIOR DESIGN BASED ON STAFF'S EVALUATION. THIS PROPERTY IS LIKELY TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE LANDMARK DESIGNATION UNDER CRITERIA B WITH THE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE FROM THE DATE OF CONSTRUCTION IN 1961 THROUGH THE RESIDENCY OF EDWARD FRANK'S FAMILY NINE THROUGH 1979. AND CRITERIA C WITH THE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE FROM THE DATE OF CONSTRUCTION OF 1961. AND IF APPROVED, IT WOULD BE KNOWN AS THE FRANK HOUSE, 42 10 CALIFORNIA AVENUE. THIS IS A ONE STORY RESIDENCE WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1964, AND IT WAS DESIGNED IN THE CUSTOM MODERN RANCH STYLE. THE BUILDING WAS COMMISSIONED BY DR AND MRS. PAUL DOROTHY HARTSTEIN. UH, HE WAS A PROMINENT LOCAL PHYSICIAN AND THE FOUNDER AND CHIEF OF STAFF DOCTORS HOSPITAL OF LAKEWOOD. AND THE BUILDING WAS DESIGNED BY ARCHITECT STANLEY. VAL GOLDEN. GOLDEN WAS PART OF THE ALLIED ARCHITECT'S FIRM WHO DESIGNED THE TERRACE THEATER IN THE 19 60 76 LONG BEACH CITY HALL AND LIBRARY. HE WAS THE PRINCIPAL OF THE A E NINE, A GROUP OF LONG BEACH ARCHITECTS THAT INCLUDED KENNETH WING, GORDON POWERS AND DELMA. DANIEL GOLDIN WAS A LEADER OF THE MODERNIZATION DESIGN OF LONG BEACH IN THE 1960S AND THE SEVENTIES. AND HE DESIGNED NUMEROUS LOCAL RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INSTITUTIONAL BUILDINGS OVER THE COURSE OF HIS CAREER, WHICH WAS MOSTLY BASED HERE IN LONG BEACH. THE BUILDING IS AN EXCELLENT EXAMPLE OF THE TREND OF CUSTOM MODERN HOUSING BUILT FOR THE PROFESSIONAL CLASS, SEEKING A SUBURBAN LIFESTYLE CENTERED IN INDOOR OUTDOOR ENTERTAINMENT IN LONG BEACH IN THE MID 20TH CENTURY. THE BUILDING FEATURES A U-SHAPED HORIZONTAL FORM WITH AN INTERIOR COURTYARD POST AND BEAM CONSTRUCTION WITH SMOOTH STRUCK WALLS, LOW PITCHED ROOF WITH WIDE OVERHANGING [00:40:01] EAVES, AN OPEN INTERIOR FLOOR PLAN THAT INTEGRATES THE OUTDOORS INTO THE INTERIOR WITH THE USE OF LARGE WINDOWS AND GLASS DOORS. THE FACADE FEATURES A WIDE CONCRETE WALKWAY THAT LEADS TO A TALL FOUR PANNED WOOD INJURY DOOR FLANKED BY FIXED PANE WINDOWS OF EQUAL HEIGHT WITHIN THE INSET PORCH. THIS CUSTOM RANCH STYLE RESONANCE EXHIBITS STYLIZED CHARACTERISTICS OF THE RANCH STYLE, INCLUDING ITS EMPHASIS ON THE HORIZONTAL FORM, THE INTERIOR COURTYARD, AND THE PULSON BEAM CONSTRUCTION. THE HOUSE RETAINS A HIGH LEVEL OF INTEGRITY AND CHARACTER DEFINING FEATURES BASED ON STAFF'S EVALUATION. THIS PROPERTY IS ELIGIBLE FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION UNDER CRITERIA C FOR THE RANCH STYLE, AND AS THE WORK OF A MASTER ARCHITECT WITH A PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE FROM THE DATE OF DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION IN 1964, IF APPROVED, THIS HOUSE WOULD BE KNOWN AS THE DR. PAUL AND DOROTHY HARTSTEIN HOUSE. THE THIRD LANDMARK REQUEST IS 44 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE. IT'S A TWO STORY RESIDENCE, WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1936 AND WAS DESIGNED IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARCHITECTURAL STYLE BY ARCHITECT HUGH R DAVIES. DAVIES WAS A PROMINENT PROLIFIC ARCHITECT. HIS MOST NOTED FOR HIS INSTITUTIONAL BUILDING DESIGN. HIS EARLY CAREER INCLUDED PRIMARY ARCHITECTURAL DESIGNS AND REVIVAL STYLES. HIS CONCEPT FOR THE 1928 PACIFIC SOUTHWEST EXPOSITION IN LONG BEACH FEATURED A T UH, TUNISIAN THEME. IN 1930S, HIS DESIGN SHIFTED TO THE NEW MODERN AESTHETIC. ONE OF HIS MOST WELL-KNOWN COMMISSIONS WAS THE, UM, HUNTINGTON PARK CIVIC CENTER. DAVEY SERVED AS THE PRESIDENT OF THE LONG BEACH ARCHITECTURAL CLUB IN 1930. HE WAS ALSO A MEMBER OF THE LONG BEACH CITY PLANNING COMMISSION IN THE TWENTIES AND AGAIN IN THE FORTIES. HIS OTHER WORKS INCLUDED THE POST OFFICE AND FEDERAL BUILDING IN LONG BEACH COMMUNITY HOSPITAL OF LONG BEACH, LONG BEACH RECREATIONAL PARK CLUBHOUSE, LONG BEACH POLYTECH TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOL. UM, THE POST OFFICE IS ON THE NATIONAL REGISTER FOR HISTORIC BUILDINGS. HUGH DAVIES AND HIS FAMILY RESIDED HERE AT 44 0 1 MYRTLE FROM 1937 UNTIL 1941. ALTHOUGH THE RESIDENCE IS A GOOD EXAMPLE OF ITS STYLE, IT'S NOT A GOOD REPRESENTATION OF DAVIES'S SIGNIFICANT WORK AS AN ARCHITECT. THEREFORE, IT'S NOT CONSIDERED, UM, SIGNIFICANT FOR ITS DESIGN. UH, AS A MASTER ARCHITECT, THE BUILDING FEATURES AN L-SHAPED FOOTPRINT, A FLAT ROOF, A FLAT FRONT FACADE, EXTERIOR WALLS OF STUCCO, WOOD SIDING, GLASS AND STEEL FRAME WINDOWS. LARGE FLOOR TO CEILING GLASS WINDOWS PROVIDE VIEWS OF THE INTERIOR ENCLOSED BACKYARD COURTYARD. THE BUILDING WAS CONSTRUCTED AS AN EX EXPOSITION HOME AND FOR THE THEN FAST GROWING BIXBY KNOLL'S NEIGHBORHOOD AND IT WAS NAMED THE 20TH CENTURY HOUSE. THE BUILDING'S ARCHITECTURE IS NEAR PRISTINE EXAMPLE OF THE INTERNATIONAL STYLE. THE SURFACES AND MATERIALS ARE NEARLY ALL ORIGINAL, INCLUDING THE HORIZONTAL RED SIDING, UH, MAINTAINING ITS AN ORIGINAL WHITE AESTHETIC. THE BUILDING, UM, WAS DESIGNED TO DEMONSTRATE THE UNIQUE STREAMLINED STYLE THAT SPOKE TO THE FUTURE. THE BUILDING FEATURES THE IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS OF THE INTERNATIONAL STYLE, INCLUDING ITS HER RECTANGLE FORM, THE LACK OF ORNAMENTATION, THE FLAT ROOF, LARGE PANES OF GLASS, THE OPEN INTERIOR PLAN, AND THE INCLUSION OF INVA INNOVATIVE BUILDING MATERIALS AND TECHNIQUES. TODAY, THIS HOUSE RETAINS A HIGH LEVEL OF INTEGRITY WITH INTACT CHARACTER DEFINING FEATURES BASED ON STAFF'S EVALUATION. THE PROPERTY IS ELIGIBLE FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION UNDER CRITERIA C WITH A PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE FROM THE DATE OF CONSTRUCTION IN 1936. AND IF APPROVED, IT WOULD BE KNOWN AS THE 20TH CENTURY HOUSE. UH, STAFF RECOMMENDS THAT THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION REVIEW THE BACKGROUND MATERIAL EXCEPT THE FINDINGS AND RECOMMEND THAT CITY COUNCIL APPROVE THE THREE LANDMARK DESIGNATION REQUEST FOR 82 REVO ALTO CANAL, 42 10 CALIFORNIA AVENUE AND 44 0 1 MYRTLE AVENUE. AND STAFF RECOM RECOMMENDS THAT THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION, UM, RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE 14 MILLS ACT CONTRACTS. THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, I CAN ANSWER THEM AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU, GINA. THAT WAS A LOT OF WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE FOR ALL OF THOSE PROJECTS. UH, AT THIS TIME, DOES THE COMMISSION HAVE ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS [00:45:01] FOR THE STAFF? UM, COMMISSIONER GFI, UM, I'M SORRY, I MISSED WHICH CRITERIA. THE 42 10 CALIFORNIA AVENUE HOUSE FELL UNDER. WAS IT C CRITERIA? C. OKAY. FOR THE RANCH STYLE AND THE WORK OF THE MASTER ARCHITECT. SO, SO BOTH OF THOSE PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE AND MASTER ARCHITECT? THAT'S CORRECT. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER COMMISSIONERS WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT AT THIS TIME? IF THERE IS NONE, UH, WE'LL NOW TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT. ANYONE THAT IS HERE THAT HAS A HOUSE OR PROPERTY ON THE AGENDA ITEM THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THAT PARTICULAR ITEM, PLEASE APPROACH THE, THE STAND. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES. IF THERE ARE NONE, ARE THERE ANY COMMENTS VIRTUALLY? IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE USE THE RAISED HAND FEATURE OR DIAL STAR NINE. NOW THERE APPEARS TO BE, THERE APPEARS TO BE ONE PUBLIC COMMENT. GINA, MAY, MAY I SPEAK? HI, GINA. UM, YOU HAVE BEEN UNMUTED. YOU HAVE, UH, THREE MINUTES TO GO AHEAD AND MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT STARTING NOW. UM, JUST A CLARIFICATION. UM, THANK YOU FOR ALL THE HARD WORK. UM, MY ADDRESS WAS REFERRED TO AS 7 4 9 DAWSON AVENUE AND 7 4 3 DAWSON AVENUE. I JUST WANNA CLARIFY THAT IT'S 7 4 6 DAWSON AVENUE AS INDICATED ON THE SLIDE JUST FOR THE RECORDS. THANK YOU. THERE APPEARS TO BE NO FURTHER COMMENT AT THIS TIME. ARE THERE ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION? IF THERE ARE NONE, MADAM CLERK, COULD YOU CALL FOR THE VOTE PLEASE? COMMISSIONER KOFF, IF YOU'D LIKE TO GIVE A VERBAL VOTE, I CAN TAKE THAT. YES. THANK YOU. MOTION CARRIES. THANK YOU. MOVING ON TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER FOUR, [4. 24-54292 Recommendation to make an appointment to the Long Beach Navy Memorial Heritage Trust (Navy Trust) Board of Trustees.       Suggested Action: Approve recommendation. ] RECOMMENDATION TO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT TO THE LONG BEACH NAVY MEMORIAL HERITAGE TRUST BOARD OF TRUSTEES. MAY HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND, PLEASE. IT HAS BEEN MOVED BY COMMISSIONER GFE AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER PIZZA. THANK YOU. MAY WE HAVE THE STAFF PRESENTATION PROJECT PLAN EARLIER? A HUNDRED PERCENT, YEAH. WE'LL GIVE THE STAFF REPORT ON THIS ITEM. UH, THANK YOU EVERYONE. UH, SO FOR TONIGHT'S ITEM, UH, JUST TO KIND OF FRAME IT, UH, THE, THE CHC, THE CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION, UH, GETS TO MAKE AN ANNUAL APPOINTMENT TO THE NAVY TRUST. UH, THE NAVY TRUST HAS A MUCH LONGER NAME, SO I'M GONNA CONTINUE TO REFER TO IT AS THE NAVY TRUST. BUT FOR THE RECORD, UH, THE NAME OF THE FORMAL NAME OF THE NAVY TRUST IS THE LONG BEACH NAVY MEMORIAL HERITAGE ASSOCIATION. UM, THE NAVY TRUST, UH, IS A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. UH, THAT NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION, UH, WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1998 IN RESPONSE TO, UH, THE LOSS OF THE UNITED STATES NAVAL STATION. HERE, UH, THE NAVAL STATION IS IMPORTANT, UH, BECAUSE OF ITS SITE PLANNING, LANDSCAPING, AND ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. UH, AND ABOVE ALL, IT WAS, UH, DESIGNED BY, UH, THE REVERED ARCHITECT, UH, PAUL REVERE WILLIAMS. UM, WHY THIS IS IMPORTANT, UH, IS, IS BECAUSE THIS, THIS ORGANIZATION WAS ESTABLISHED TO, UH, FUND HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECTS HERE IN THE CITY. UH, TO DATE, UH, THEY HAVE, UH, GRANTED, UH, FUNDING IN ABOUT THE RANGE OF ABOUT $4 MILLION FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECTS. UM, SO THIS, UH, BOARD, UH, THAT YOU'LL BE MAKING [00:50:01] AN, UM, AN APPOINTMENT TO, UH, IS A NINE MEMBER BOARD. UH, THE CHC GETS TO MAKE, UH, THREE APPOINTMENTS TO THIS PARTICULAR BOARD. UH, THEY'RE LISTED IN THE STAFF REPORT AND, UH, THERE IS A MUCH, UH, MORE DETAILED PRESENTATION, UH, THAT YOU HAVE AS AN ATTACHMENT AS WELL. THAT WAS FROM 2021, UM, AND HAS A LOT MORE BACKGROUND ABOUT WHAT THIS, UH, ORGANIZATION DOES. UH, BUT TONIGHT, UH, THE NAVY TRUST, UH, IN FRONT OF YOU, THE NAVY TRUST HAS REQUESTED, UH, A REAPPOINTMENT OF, UH, ROBERTA JEANETTE. UM, SHE, UH, HAS BEEN ON THE ORGANIZATION, UH, BEFORE. SO THIS IS A REAPPOINTMENT REQUEST. SO THIS COMMISSION, UH, GETS TO CONSIDER THAT. AND, UH, EITHER REAPPOINT OR, UM, WE CAN ALSO DO ANOTHER ACTION TO HAVE ANOTHER PERSON, UH, BE, UH, APPOINTED. SO THAT IS IT. WE, UH, FOR MY PART OF THE PRESENTATION, I'LL GO AHEAD AND, UH, LEAVE IT OPEN FOR QUESTIONS. I I DO HAVE A QUESTION. AS A CURRENT MEMBER OF THE LONG BEACH NAVY MEMORIAL, AM I ALLOWED TO VOTE ON THIS? UH, WE APOLOGIZE FOR THAT ONE. SO I THINK JUST AS, UH, OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, UH, MAYBE WHAT WE'LL DO IS, UM, WE CAN PROBABLY FORWARD THIS ONE TO, UH, THE NEXT MEETING, UH, RIGHT NOW, BECAUSE, UH, WE'RE AT FOUR COMMISSION VOTES. WE DO HAVE A QUORUM, BUT IF ONE PERSON DOES NOT VOTE, UH, THEN THAT MEANS, UH, THAT THE VOTE WOULD BE INVALIDATED. SO, UH, SO YEAH, WE'LL GO AHEAD AND RESCHEDULE THIS ONE, UH, FOR ANOTHER MEETING AND, UH, WE CAN GO FROM THERE. DO WE, DO WE NEED TO PULL THIS MOTION AND MAKE A MOTION TO TABLE? WHAT WE'LL NEED TO DO IS MAKE A MOTION TO WITHDRAW THE ITEM AND THEN WE'LL VOTE ON THAT. OKAY, LET'S DO THAT. UM, LET'S, UM, MAKE A MOTION TO PULL THE CURRENT MOTION ON THE TABLE AND DO WE HAVE A MOVER? AND THEN A SECOND WE HAVE A MOTION FROM VICE-CHAIRMAN GU AND A SECOND FROM COMMISSIONER PIZZA. ANY DISCUSSION ON THAT? YES. AND BEFORE WE MOVE FORWARD, IS THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT FROM ANYBODY IN THE AUDIENCE ON THIS ITEM? IS THERE ANY CHANCE WE COULD HEAR FROM THE CANDIDATE AND SHE COULD I'LL BE HERE IN THE NEXT WEEK? YES. SO, I MEAN, SHE'S FREE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT, BUT, UM, IF IT'S SOMETHING PERTINENT TO THE VOTE, THEN SHE SHOULD PROBABLY, SHE MIGHT HAVE TO REPEAT HER COMMENTS AT THE NEXT MEETING. OKAY. THANK YOU. TECH, TECHNICALLY HER TERM IS EXPIRED ON JUNE 30TH, BUT WE SHOULD CONTINUE YOUR SERVICE UNTIL WE HAVE A VOTE, UH, ON THE COMMISSION. IS THERE ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS AT THIS TIME? UH, VIRTUAL OR IN CHAMBER? IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THIS [00:55:01] ITEM, PLEASE USE THE RAISE HAND FEATURE OR DIAL NINE. NOW THERE APPEARS TO BE NO FURTHER PUBLIC COMMENT. THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER COMMENTS FROM THE COMMISSIONERS? DO I HAVE TO READ TO MYSELF? YOU DON'T NEED TO RECUSE YOURSELF TO WITHDRAW THE ITEM. OKAY, MADAM CLERK, UH, CAN WE CALL FOR THE VOTE? YES. MOTION CARRIES. THANK YOU. AT THIS TIME, IT'S OPEN TO [PUBLIC COMMENT Opportunity to address the Cultural Heritage Commission on non-agenda items. Each speaker is limited to three minutes to make their comments unless extended by the Chair.] THE PUBLIC COMMENT. UH, WE'LL TAKE NON AGENDA, PUBLIC COMMENT. IF ANYONE LIKE TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEM NOT LISTED ON THE AGENDA, PLEASE LINE UP AT THE MICROPHONE. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES. ARE THERE ANY VIRTUAL COMMENTS? SIR, IF YOU'D LIKE TO APPROACH THE SPEAKER PODIUM AND YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS, PLEASE FOR THE RECORD? SURE. UH, , UH, LONG BEACH. UH, TWO BLOCKS AWAY FROM HERE. SHALL I BEGIN? , UH, I JUST WANNA SAY THANK YOU TO THE COUNCIL AND TO THE CITY OF LONG BEACH. MY WIFE AND I JUST, UH, PURCHASED A HOME HERE TWO BLOCKS AWAY. AND, UH, YOU KNOW, FOR AS CRAZY AS, UH, PRICES ARE RIGHT NOW, UH, I THINK LONG BEACH IS DOING A LOT TO HELP AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE TO HELP MAKE HOME OWNERSHIP POSSIBLE. AND THEN ADDITIONALLY, WITH THINGS LIKE THE MILLS ACT AND OTHER THINGS WHERE WE HAVE A HISTORIC HOME, UM, IT'S GOING A LONG WAY TO HELP US, UH, KIND OF MAKE OUR HOME HABITABLE 'CAUSE IT'S BEEN IN DISREPAIR FOR A LONG TIME. SO I JUST WANNA SAY THANK YOU TO EVERYONE HERE AND TO THE CITY OF LONG BEACH FOR THAT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER COMMENTS? VIRTUALLY, IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE USE THE RAISE HAND FUNCTION OR DIALED STAR NINE. NOW THERE APPEARS TO BE NO PUBLIC COMMENT AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU. UM, ARE [ANNOUNCEMENTS] THERE ANY ANNOUNCEMENTS FROM THE COMMISSIONERS? UH, I HAVE ONE COMMENT AND I WANNA THANK, UH, BOTH STAFF AND THE COMMISSION. UH, THERE WAS AN AGENDA ITEM THAT WE APPROVED LAST YEAR IS THE RESTORATION OF THE LONG BEACH AIRPORT, WPA MOSAIC MURALS. IT'S, UH, THEY'RE CELEBRATING THEIR HUNDREDTH YEAR IN OPERATION, BUT THEY HAD THE, UH, RIBBON CUTTING LAST SATURDAY. IT WAS WELL ATTENDED, PROBABLY OVER A THOUSAND PEOPLE. THE MAYOR WAS THERE. AND IT JUST GOES TO SHOW THAT PRESERVATION WORKS IN THIS CITY. AND WHAT WE DID WITH THE, UM, UH, WITH PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS AND THE FUNDS THAT WERE AVAILABLE TO RESTORE THAT TO ITS ORIGINALITY, THERE WERE OVER 1.6 MILLION PIECES OF MOSAIC TILE THAT WERE PAINSTAKINGLY PRESERVED. AND I GOTTA SAY THAT, UH, IT'S NICE TO SEE SOME OF THESE PROJECTS COMING INTO FRUITION. IF THERE ARE NO OTHER COMMENTS, UH, [ADJOURNMENT] ON NO OTHER OBJECTIONS, I DECLARE THIS MEETING ADJOURN. THANK YOU. * This transcript was created by voice-to-text technology. The transcript has not been edited for errors or omissions, it is for reference only and is not the official minutes of the meeting.